Is Print Advertising A Dying Art?
Saturday, October 15th, 2011I’m in the advertising business. At least that is what they’re still calling it. Significant blocks of time transpire, however, where nothing resembling advertising passes through my company’s job queue, or past my desk. I checked again simply to make sure. Yep, Web site designs, optimized web site re-write, corporate identity package, radio spots (there’s something), video production and streaming, html emails, logo designs, CD package design, article development and submissions, sign graphics, travel brochure, banner ads, SEO work (plenty of it), news releases. I was right – no full-page advertising in queue this week – no string of print ad copywriting assignments, no huddling using the creative team to concept to have an upcoming campaign (radio spot concept and copy is complete).
Oh, sure we’ve been frequently required to write some so-called “ad copy” full of key words. I hold hope that someday, search engines like google will code their bots to rank search engine results according to “strength of benefit” (SOB).
To finish it off, I even had a friend who sells print travel advertising begin to let me know how within the chronilogical age of Tivo, broadcast advertising was a short-timer within the marketing mix. I didn’t have the heart to inquire about him if he felt the same about print advertising, based on the proliferation of online tools open to advertisers…those who sustain my business and his.
All of these issues led me to wonder if print advertising is really a dying art?
I peeled myself from my computer, where I’ve been engrossed in three hours of blurry-eyed internet research, finding better, more efficient and cost-effective promotional opportunities for clients, including SEO, PPC, RSS, forums, article submissions, directory listings, AdWords, search engine advertising (well, really not advertising, is it?), podcasting, blogging, webcasting, as well as on and on. Where did time go?
Deciding that my work day was over, I left work. Later, I walked into my family room to find my beautiful and charming wife lounged about the sofa reading Southern Living. She looked peaceful, blissful even, there flipping the pages and sipping her freshly brewed chai tea latte with milk and Splenda. I sat down beside her, silent, and observed as she lost herself within the magazine. Once or twice she uttered “what?” I said “Nothing. I’m just enjoying the quiet.”
She scanned it all, read some of it, including ads. She even turned down corners on some of the pages – “Must be considered a recipe,” I thought. Then it struck me: she’s been carrying this out since I met her, before that. She wasn’t lounged on the couch with a laptop diligently, wirelessly downloading web site after web page of 256-color heaven. Why is this so? I mean, ads in the online version of the print counterparts tend to be less intrusive about the reader. Right?
Okay, now I had been curious. And that i attempted to do some quick and meaningful research…online obviously. What I found would be a confusing array of seemingly contradictory information from various sources, some known, many unknown. Some said magazine and dailies readership was rising due to the internet. The other side was saying, you guessed it, the alternative.
I shut down my computer.
I’m going with my intuition on this. My very own experience has taught me that sometimes your hunch on going with one headline over another is dead-center. So, here’ go.
Magazines – as well as newspapers (despite recent decline) – and those who decide to advertise inside them aren’t going anywhere. What they are called might change, but periodicals like a media form has made it into the stubborn fabric in our culture. We read. We love to to look at things, and also at our own pace. A magazine, within this light, is much more user friendly than a computer. No typing is needed. No booting up is necessary. No downloads delay us, just a cup of the favorite brand of chai tea latte to sip between articles. Was this exactly the same brand advertised in Southern Living? Probably.
So, I’ve come to the final outcome that the internet has created another media (despite many arguments the internet is not a “media”). And, it provides many possibilities to disclose and distribute information, and promote a company, individuals, group, services and products. And it does so – brilliantly in some instances, and clumsily in others – just like other media…imperfectly.
But, as for print advertising? I believe that over the years, it will retain its importance in the marketing mix. In fact, In my opinion it is more segmented and targeted, because the media which contain it and enjoy it, will still be instructed to evolve.
In response to my travel advertising friend, who prophesied the death of television advertising…perhaps I’ll cover that in another article.
For more than Two decades, Mick Danskin has been obsessing over advertising and marketing strategy and execution. He brings that passion, together with an open mind along with a team of seasoned professionals to his clients’ marketing communication challenges.